• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Art of Composing

Let's learn to compose together.

  • Start Here
  • Courses
  • Video
  • Podcast
  • Articles
  • About
    • Contact
    • Listen to My Music
  • Composing Resources
    • Recommended Books
    • Orchestration Resources
    • Forum
    • Archives
You are here: Home / Questions / Modal borrowing

Modal borrowing

June 23, 2017 By

Forum › Modal borrowing
0 Vote Up Vote Down
Ilkka U asked 5 years ago

Hi,
in regards to 201 module 1 lesson 2, with modal borrowing you talk about substituting “vi” with “flat VI”. For C major I understand this as C-minor A is flattened(VI=Am->bVI=Ab). Does this rule for “VI” to “bVI” apply to all keys? Is there a “rule” to follow with modal borrowing like “flat X” or do one need to always go with “go to same key with minor, and substitute from there (like vi to VI, iv to IV, ii to iidim)?

1 Answers
0 Vote Up Vote Down
Jon Brantingham Staff answered 5 years ago

The best way to think of it is the root of the vi chord in major, moves downward by a half-step, and the chord is a major chord instead of a minor chord.

So C major has A minor as the vi chord, and A♭ major as the ♭VI chord.

Db major has a Bb minor as the vi chord, and a B𝄫 major as the ♭VI chord.

C# major on the other hand as an A# minor as the vi chord, and an A major as the ♮VI chord. In this case, we call it a ♮VI instead of a ♭VI.

Primary Sidebar

Most Important Topics

  • How to Compose Music
  • My Free Composition Course
  • Full Beginner’s Course on Composition
  • Orchestration Resources
  • Unlocking the Mysteries of Diatonic Harmony
  • Functional Harmony
  • Books on Music Composition: A Composer’s Reading List
  • The Art of Modulation, Part 2: Common Chord Modulation
  • Why V65, V43, V42?

What Do You Want to Learn?

  • Creativity (12)
  • Film Scoring (3)
  • Form (8)
  • Fundamentals (7)
  • Getting Started (3)
  • Harmony (18)
  • Melody (8)
  • Musical Inspiration (13)
  • My Compositions (13)
  • My Journey (7)
  • Orchestration (2)
  • Podcast (13)
  • Process (31)
  • Read (60)
  • Science (6)
  • Songwriting (2)
  • Theory (12)
  • Video (16)
  • Work (5)

Recent Posts

  • The Two Critical Habits of Songwriting
  • How to Become a Songwriter if You’re a Composer
  • Why Art of Composing Exists: To Make Better Composers
  • The Science of Becoming a Better Composer
  • Build Your Craft: Learn the Melody and Chord Progression in Mozart’s Lacrimosa
  • What Are Inversions
  • Composing Without An Instrument
  • Music and Time: Theme Types
  • Music and Time: The Basic Idea
  • Music and Time: What Are Formal Functions?
  • How I Setup My Scoring Template
  • More on Sketching
  • Five Tips for Better Sketching
  • Composing a Chord Progression
  • Hearing Loss and Composers
  • Five Minute Speed Composing Session
  • Dealing with Writer’s Block
  • Feeling Stuck Composing? You’re Probably Not Defining Creative Problems.
  • Defining Creative Problems
  • Do I need to play piano to compose?

Footer CTA

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • FAQs
  • Login
  • Merch
  • Courses

Copyright © 2022 · Art of Composing